Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Fort Lauderdale Probate Lawyer
Get In Touch With Our Team 954-764-4330
  • Facebook

When the Person Settling the Estate Becomes the Defendant: Can Florida Beneficiaries Sue a Personal Representative?

CoupleWill

Most beneficiaries never expect to end up in conflict with the person handling a loved one’s estate. But when distributions stall, accounts go unexplained, or an estate asset ends up in the wrong hands, a hard question comes up: can the personal representative actually be sued? Under Florida law, yes, but the details matter. Our Fort Lauderdale breach of fiduciary duty attorneys regularly help beneficiaries understand where a particular situation fits within that framework.

The Legal Hook: A Trustee-Level Duty

Under Section 733.609 of the Florida Statutes, a personal representative’s fiduciary duty is the same as that of a trustee of an express trust, and the personal representative is liable to interested persons for damage or loss resulting from a breach of that duty. Section 733.602 adds that the personal representative must observe the standards of care that apply to trustees and settle the estate as expeditiously and efficiently as the estate’s best interests allow.

That standard is demanding, but it governs conduct, not results. A falling market or a slow buyer does not, by itself, mean anyone did anything wrong.

Which Hat Is the Personal Representative Wearing?

A personal representative can be sued in two very different capacities. Claims against the estate itself are generally brought against the personal representative in a representative capacity. Claims seeking to hold the person individually responsible are a different matter. Under Section 733.619, a personal representative is individually liable for torts committed in the course of administration only if personally at fault.

For beneficiaries, the distinction is more than technical. A judgment against the estate may simply shrink the pool that everyone shares. A surcharge against the fiduciary personally is aimed at making the estate whole from the individual’s own resources.

Where Claims Tend to Arise, and Where They Stall

Disputes frequently grow out of patterns like these:

  • Buying estate property, or selling it to a relative or business partner, without court approval or informed consent
  • Mixing estate funds with personal accounts
  • Leaving real estate uninsured or allowing it to deteriorate
  • Ignoring or delaying requests for inventory and accounting information
  • Favoring one beneficiary over others in timing or valuation

Florida law takes conflicted transactions especially seriously. Section 733.610 makes a sale to the personal representative, or any transaction affected by the personal representative’s conflict of interest, voidable by an interested person unless the will or a contract with the decedent authorized it, the court approved it after notice, or the objecting person consented after fair disclosure.

Not every grievance becomes a viable claim, though. Acts that were authorized at the time generally do not create liability under Section 733.602(2). Some wills contain exculpatory language, although Section 733.620 makes those clauses unenforceable to the extent they would excuse bad faith or reckless indifference. Costs also cut both ways. Section 733.609 directs courts to award taxable costs, including attorney’s fees, in these actions, and the court may charge those costs against a party’s share of the estate.

Talking It Through With Counsel

Every estate raises its own mix of facts, documents, and deadlines. An attorney can review the records and explain how the process generally works. At Edward J. Jennings, P.A., our Fort Lauderdale probate litigation lawyers have handled fiduciary disputes throughout Broward County for years. When you are ready to talk, call us at 954-764-4330 or send us a message through our online form.

Source:

http://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0700-0799/0733/Sections/0733.609.html

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn